Tuesday, July 05, 2005

Vector Addition for Identifiers

Kim Cameron's 4th Law of Identity deals with directional identifiers

A universal identity system must support both "omni-directional" identifiers for use by public entities and "unidirectional" identifiers for use by private entities, thus facilitating discovery while preventing unnecessary release of correlation handles.

As explanation, "identity has direction, not just magnitude".

In math, something specified by both a direction and a magnitude is called a vector and are usually represented by an arrow pointing in the appropriate direction with a length corresponding to the magnitude. Like normal objects with just magnitude (scalars), two vectors can be added together. But, the addition has to take into account the direction of both vectors. To add vector A to vector B, the tail of B is joined to the head of A, the arrow from the tail of A to the head of B is the resultant sum.

The relevance of vector addition to federated identifiers is that 'adding' two identifiers for a user must also take into account their direction, i.e. the provider(s) for which the identifiers are targetted. Federated identifiers only make sense when qualified by the entities that will recognize them and be able to map them into some local account.

In many situations, a service provider may have a shared identifier for a given user with an identity provider and the identity provider may have a (different, when privacy is required) shared identifier with another service provider for the same user. If the first and second service providers are to communicate on behalf of the user, they need a means to refer to that user. Assuming that the two servie providers don't wish to themselves establish a permanent shared identifier, the identity provider can help by mapping from the first identifier to the second. The first provider asks the identity provider for an appropriate identifier to use when talking to the second service provider about the user in question, and the identity provider returns the appropriate identifier that the second provider will recognize (likely encrypted for the second provider).


If the identifier shared between the first service provider and the identity provider is vector A, and that shared between the identity provider and the second service provider is vector B, the mapped (and encrypted result) is logically equivalent to the sum - vector A+B.

This is shown in the diagram (using different terminology - web service consumer (WSC) and web service provider (WSP) for the first and second service providers and security token service (STS) for the identity provider).

No comments: